Click photo to enlarge
The Santa Clara Unified School District Board of Education meeting in the... (Nhat V. Meyer)
The worst fears of parents and staff in the Santa Clara Unified School District are coming true following the election last November of two new trustees, Chris Stampolis and Michele Ryan. They have been just as divisive, micromanaging, petty and unreasonable as those who knew Stampolis, in particular, warned before the election.
After voters ignored the advice of education leaders in the community, Stampolis and Ryan formed a majority coalition with two other trustees with a similar bent, Ina Bendis and Christine Koltermann. The results are as predicted: a board inappropriately involving itself in the nitty-gritty of school management, interrogating staff and angering and frightening teachers and administrators. An estimated 20 percent of the top leadership, including widely respected Superintendent Bobbie Plough, are departing. Ryan has even gone after a student who dared to criticize the members' toxic behavior.
The departure of so many essential people is a serious problem; the district has been unable, for example, to fill the crucial budget officer role for more than six months. The community is taking notice, with a petition on the Change.org web site declaring a "vote of no confidence" garnering more than 1,800 signatures and counting. Now is the time to recruit quality candidates for 2014, when four seats will be up for election, including those held by Bendis and Koltermann.
Mercury News reporter

Advertisement

Sharon Noguchi detailed the disarray last week. Board members are usurping the authority of their staff; they recently held a detailed discussion, for example, of one school's master schedule, in response to a complaint from a friend of several board members. Trustees are not supposed to resolve complaints themselves; they refer them to administrators and ensure follow-through.
Some teachers at Bracher Elementary have been "working to rule" -- to the letter of their contract -- partly to protest Stampolis' decision to remain as school site council president, an inappropriate dual role. Stampolis' behavior is sometimes so outrageous, it's as though he is either completely clueless about the importance of personal relationships or hell-bent on intentionally destroying them.
Ryan's behavior, too, is strange for someone who claims to want to help students. She went after a high school junior, attempting to shame him after he compared the board room to a "gas chamber" during a meeting. Perhaps it wasn't the best metaphor, but Ryan claims it was an affront to Bendis, who is Jewish. Ryan absurdly wrote to the Anti-Defamation League, and the group's response is on Thursday's board agenda. That's quite an example she's setting as an education leader.
Worst of all, the district -- while viewed generally as solid -- has significant problems the trustees should be focused on solving, including the wide achievement gap between Latino students and their white and Asian peers. But they will get nowhere by alienating everyone around them.
The Santa Clara Unified board needs to refocus on its primary role: setting policy. The only way that can happen is with new members.